Printable worksheet

Carrier Comparison Sheet

Compare insurers and policies using the same fields instead of comparing premium alone.

Last updated: August 11, 2026Informational guidance

Before you begin

Compare insurers and policies using the same fields instead of comparing premium alone.

Your entries are not submittedThis worksheet runs in your browser. Print it, save it as a PDF, or copy the notes into your own secure records.
All worksheets

Carrier Comparison Sheet

DoneItem and purposeYour notes
Insurer and legal company name
Record the exact underwriting company, not only the consumer brand.
State license and availability
Verify the company or agent with your state insurance department.
Policy form
Record HO-3, HO-5, HO-6, HO-4, DP-3, or another form.
Dwelling limit
Copy the limit and any extended or guaranteed replacement provision.
Property settlement
Record replacement cost, actual cash value, and separate roof wording.
Deductibles
List every applicable flat or percentage deductible.
Exclusions
Note excluded causes of loss, property, uses, and conditions.
Endorsements
Mark each requested addition as included, optional, or unavailable.
Claims access
Record reporting channels, emergency access, and adjuster contact process.
Independent checks
Save regulator, complaint, and financial-strength sources used.

How to finish the review

  1. Mark uncertain answers instead of guessing.
  2. Attach the quote, declarations page, and form or endorsement that supports each answer.
  3. Ask the agent or carrier to resolve differences in writing.
  4. Repeat the same fields for every quote so price is compared on equal terms.